Rhubarb, raspberry & vanilla mascarpone sponge cake recipe

Rhubarb, raspberry & vanilla mascarpone sponge cake

When my cookbook was launched I was lucky enough to go on a NZ book tour, and I shared the trip with a clever cake baker, Jordan Rondel, who had just released her own cookbook ‘The Caker’.  I like her style of cakes – they have substance and density and they are always moist. She doesn’t like perfect-looking food and neither do I (see picture above!) – we create dishes with character.  So when I wanted a delicious plain sponge cake recipe to cram together with my beautiful fillings, I chose one of hers. It’s a little different to a classic sponge, and I love it. Buttery, crumbly and delicious.

Lots of people have a sponge-making phobia, but it’s really not hard to do, I promise. I’ve given you few tips at the bottom of this page, and it’s well worth a read before you start. Handy tip: Check the expiration date on your baking powder! It does expire; and I had made four crappy flat cakes and uttered every swear word under the sun before I realised what was wrong. If in doubt, buy a new packet. You’ll have lots of  rhubarb compote left over, it’s delicious with ice cream, yoghurt or on cereal or buttered toast.


300g butter, softened slightly
300g caster sugar
2 tsp pure vanilla essence
6 free range eggs, at room temperature
400g plain flour
4 tsp baking powder
1 cup milk (preferably whole milk)

Rhubarb & raspberry compote
400-500g rhubarb stalks, chopped
1 cup frozen or fresh raspberries
½ cup sugar
Zest of 1 lemon
Small pinch of salt

Mascarpone cream
200g mascarpone
1 ½ cups icing sugar
1 cup cream, whipped
1 tsp vanilla paste (or scrape seeds out of 2 vanilla pods)

To garnish
Fresh berries if it’s the right season, freeze-dried if not


Preheat the oven to 180c. Grease and line 2 x 22cm diameter cake tins.

In the bowl of an electric mixer or using a hand held beater, cream the butter and sugar until pale, light and fluffy*. Add the vanilla and then the eggs, one at a time, beating for about a minute after each addition. Scrape down the sides every now and then with a spatula.

Sift the flour and baking powder into the mixture, and add the milk. Beat gently until everything is thoroughly mixed in and smooth, then stop – don’t keep beating away once it’s properly mixed (scrape down the sides too). Divide the batter evenly between the two tins.

Bake for 30 minutes or until golden brown in colour and springy to the touch. Allow the cakes to cool for 10 minutes before turning out onto a cooling rack.

Heat all the ingredients in a pot over a medium heat and simmer for around 15 minutes or until it’s thick and jammy. Leave to cool in a bowl.

Beat the icing sugar, mascarpone and lemon zest until thick, then fold in the cream.

To assemble
Once the cakes are completely cool, trim the top of one so it’s flat if need be, and place on a platter. Spread on a layer of the compote then and mascarpone cream. Don’t be too generous here as the layers will slide apart if there’s too much filling and it will be difficult to cut nicely – the amount I did in my photo above was probably a bit of an overkill!

Finish by spreading a layer of mascarpone cream on top, then garnish with fresh or freeze dried berries. Dust with icing sugar if you like. Because there is fresh cream in this cake, it is best to store it in the fridge in an airtight container for up to 3 days.


*A few cake tips – it starts with the creaming

‘Cream  butter and sugar’. It’s a common phrase, but do we actually know what the heck it means? I didn’t for a long time. Why is it important? When you cream butter and sugar, it goes light and fluffy because you’re essentially creating thousands of little air pockets, which make the end baked product lighter. If you don’t actually cream it properly, the end cake won’t work as well. You can use a cake mixer or a hand held electric beater, or you can also do it with a wooden spoon like my Mum used to. It works, it just takes longer. The butter shouldn’t be hard from the fridge, or soft and shiny, it needs to be just around room temperature (20-30 seconds on the defrost setting on the microwave works for me). Start the mixing on a low speed until the butter and sugar are combined, then turn it to high for the rest of the time (it should take about 5 minutes), making sure you scrape down the sides with a spatula. By the end, the mixture will be lovely light in colour and fluffy, not dense, and increased in volume with the air pockets. Almost more like whipped cream than the butter it started as!

Then you add the eggs one by one, which are at room temperature (soak in a bowl of warm water to warm them up from the fridge). Why one by one? Because you’re adding eggs to butter, which is a fat and the two things normally wouldn’t mix together. You’re creating an emulsion, so the eggs should be at added slowly so they can be given a chance to mix with the butter properly. By the 6th egg the mixture might look a bit split, but don’t worry about it, it’ll come together nicely when you add the dry ingredients.

These days, when I’m not writing cookbooks and dashing around the country doing foodie things, I spend most of my time gangling around in my little kitchen, creating new and exciting recipes to inspire home cooks, like you.
  1. Lisa Reply
    Hey, Im not a sponge maker, failed many times but think Il give this one ago for my mums birthday coming up, just wondering if it will still work using one big springform tin as thats all I have and then cut through the middle to assemble?
    • Chelsea Winter Reply
      Definitely! Just cook for a little longer if all the mix is in one tin - and extra 15 minutes or so.
  2. Lisa Reply
    Yay thanks for that!! will see how it go's!!
  3. sharon Reply
    I'm not normally terribly good with cakes :( Anyway I gave this a try and even though my mixer played up and I think the sponge should have been lighter it was lovely :-) I took it to friends for dinner and they were super impressed. All thanks to you Chelsea :-) Keep up the good recipes for people like me who are not always so good in the kitchen :-)
  4. Pingback: Seasonal Recipes (Spring) – Rhubarb | Mama's Style

  5. Bex Reply
    Thank you so much for the tips section! After reading it I realised something - I have NEVER had anyone or any book take the time to explain to me *why* I must do things like add eggs one at a time, etc. My natural inclination (in life generally!) is to always question directions/rules when there's no obvious reason why, so this was really helpful for me. It all makes sense now and I'll be much more likely to actually follow directions properly :)
  6. Susan Reply
    I've had a bad run with cakes, but willing to give this one a try. I don't seem to have a good sense of when to take them out - the last ones were still slightly gooey in the middle, despite a skewer coming out dry.
  7. honeybee Reply
    My sponges have never worked ...always failed ...with this info i shouldnt fail...wish me luck
  8. Pingback: Sponge Cake with Rhubarb & Raspberry Compote | The Kiwi Cook

  9. Eleanor Reply
    My mother always told me to add a little of the flour each time you add an egg. Do you know anything about this?
  10. Chucky Walsh Reply
    I used the cake recipe (but half measures) to make an upside down fruit sponge. I never have any luck with sponges...but this recipe (and the tips) made for an amazing cake!!! Making it again for the kids lunches so I can add jam in the middle!! Thank you for making believe in sponges again.
  11. George Reply
    we going to give it a go!!!

Leave a Reply


captcha *